Are Wiper Flats a Key to Better Finishes?

As machinists and shop managers/owners, achieving a good surface finish is more than a matter of aesthetics—it’s essential for functionality, fit, and overall product quality. Whether it’s a crucial aerospace component or a precision mold, a smooth and consistent finish can reduce friction, enhance performance, and even extend the lifespan of the final product. But getting that perfect finish often requires optimizing your tooling and approach. Enter wipers: a small change in your tooling setup that can lead to substantial improvements in finish quality and machining efficiency.

What Are Tools with Wiper Flats?

Imagine your standard cutting tool, designed with a primary edge that does the brunt of the cutting. A tool with a wiper flat—whether it’s an indexable insert or a solid round tool like an end mill—has a wider section behind the primary cutting edge. This wiper flat smooths out the surface left behind by the cutting edge, producing a finer finish. It’s like following a painter with a broader brush, ensuring that the strokes blend seamlessly. The result? A surface that shines under the scrutiny of a machinist’s trained eye.

Graphic showing wiper flat behind primary cutting end of a indexable milling and turning inserts

Key Advantages of Tools with Wiper Flats

For machinists, time is money—and finish quality is a point of pride and necessity. Wiper flats, whether on inserts or solid round tools, bring multiple advantages to your operations:

  1. Increased Feed Rates
    Tools with wiper flats allow you to crank up feed rates without sacrificing finish quality. How much of an increase are we talking about? In some cases, you can nearly double the feed rate while maintaining the same surface finish. This translates to significant reductions in cycle times and a bump in overall productivity. Faster feeds don’t mean sloppier results; instead, they enable efficient operations with smooth finishes.
  2. Enhanced Surface Finish
    As Justin Wilkes, a technical sales engineer at KYOCERA SGS Precision tool puts it, “it’s not just about speed”—wiper flats are engineered to leave a consistently smoother surface finish. Whether you’re chasing an aesthetic goal or a technical requirement for your next job, these features give you the edge you need.
  3. Fewer Operations
    The combination of higher feed rates and improved finishes allows you to eliminate secondary operations, reducing the total number of tool changes and setups. For example, solid end mills with wiper flats can achieve smooth finishes on pocket floors, reducing the need for additional finishing passes. This approach saves valuable spindle time and optimizes workflow.

Wiper Technology Across Tool Types: Indexable Inserts and Solid Round Tools

Wiper technology isn’t limited to one type of tool. While indexable inserts in milling cutters and turning tools are often the focus, solid round tools like end mills can also feature wiper flats. This versatility expands the range of applications where wiper technology can be leveraged, allowing machinists to optimize both broad-area and detailed finishing operations.

When deciding between these options, it’s essential to consider your specific machining requirements. Indexable inserts with wiper flats excel in situations where you need consistent, high-quality surface finishes over large areas. On the other hand, solid round tools with wiper flats shine in scenarios requiring intricate details and precision, such as pocket milling or when achieving smooth floor finishes is crucial.

SGS XPR end mill for ramping and plunging with a wiper for better floor finish
SGS Z-Carb XPR with wiper for better floor finish
Kyocera's MB45 face mill completing an operation with wiper inserts

Transitioning Between Tool Types: Matching the Technology to the Task

Choosing the right tool with wiper flats depends not only on the application but also on the material and setup. If your focus is on achieving a fine finish across a broad surface, an indexable milling cutter with wiper inserts might be the best choice. However, if you’re working on detailed features or internal pockets, a solid end mill with wiper flats can be the more precise option. Both types of tools benefit from wiper technology, but each offers unique strengths that can be leveraged for specific needs.

For instance, if you’re tackling long, uninterrupted cuts on flat surfaces, wiper inserts on a face mill can help maintain consistency. Conversely, for internal features, solid end mills equipped with wiper flats can leave floors and walls with an improved finish in fewer passes (like the XPR pictured above). Understanding the strengths of each tool type and how wiper technology enhances them can help you make the most of your operations.

The Tool Life Argument: A Double-Edged Sword

One aspect that often sparks debate among machinists is how tools with wiper flats impact tool life. On one side of the argument, these tools allow you to increase feed rates, which in turn reduces the time each tool spends in the material. In theory, this shorter contact time should mean less heat exposure per revolution, which can potentially extend tool life. Justin highlights this point: “In some cases, because a wiper allows you to feed an insert through the workpiece faster, it spends less time in contact with material, which in theory can increase your tool life, and it has in some cases.”

But there’s a flip side. Due to the larger contact area and the inherent increase in cutting pressure, wiper flats also generate additional heat—something every machinist knows is the enemy of cutting tools. Increased temperatures can accelerate wear, offsetting any gains in tool longevity achieved by the reduced contact time. Justin Wilkes, a technical sales engineer at KYOCERA SGS Precision Tool acknowledges this risk: “But at the same time, because of the natural amount of increased contact that each wiper insert has with the material and the extra heat that comes generated from that increased contact, we all know that heat is the enemy of cutting tools. It can also pull cutting tool life away from your operation as well.”

This double-edged sword means that machinists need to carefully consider their material and application to find the balance that works best.

cratering wear on a milling insert

The Machining Demos: Proof in the Chips

Let’s talk shop. In a demo turning operation, two sections of a workpiece were run at the same input feed rate using both a standard insert and a CA115P wiper insert with a DCLNR turning holder for 1/2″ IC insert. At 0.012” per revolution, the standard insert left a noticeably rougher surface, while the wiper insert produced a much finer finish. Keep in mind, this was achieved without coolant—showcasing just how effective the wiper insert can be. Introduce coolant, and the results improve even further. Solid end mills with wiper flats achieve similar results, leaving pocket floors with improved finishes.

The story doesn’t end with turning. Wiper technology also brings its advantages to milling. In a side-by-side comparison using a MB45 face mill, the difference was clear. The side milled with a standard insert had visible tool marks, while the section finished with the PR18 wiper insert was markedly smoother and more consistent.

Finish comparison between wiper & standard milling insert
Testing turning with a wiper insert compared to a standard indexable turning insert
Finish comparison between wiper and standard turning insert

Optimizing Usage: Key Takeaways

If you’re looking to boost finish quality and cut cycle times in finishing operations, tools with wiper flats are your new best friend. However, knowing when not to use them is equally important. Here’s the takeaway:

  • Use tools with wiper flats for finishing applications where lighter cuts and faster feed rates can save time and improve results.
  • Avoid using them for roughing, long-reach setups, or on materials that may smear or harden.

Elevate Every Cut

As machinists, we live for the details—those fine nuances that separate a decent part from a masterpiece. Wiper technology is a prime example of a seemingly small change that can lead to significant improvements in both efficiency and final product quality. Whether you’re taking on turning or milling tasks, with indexable inserts or solid round tools, consider where wiper flats could enhance your operations and save you time on each job.

If you’re interested in adding tools with wiper flats to your toolkit or have specific questions about integrating them into your operations, reach out to your Kyocera sales representative. And as always, keep those chips flying!

FAQ:

Q: Can wiper flats be used effectively on all types of materials?
A: While wiper flats work well on harder materials like steel and cast iron, they may not be ideal for softer materials, which can smear or experience poor surface quality. Test wiper flats on your specific material to ensure they’re suited to your application.

Q: How should I maintain or inspect tools with wiper flats?
A: Regular inspection for wear is essential, as wiper flats rely on a precise geometry to achieve a smooth finish. Any chips or uneven wear on the wiper flat edge can impact finish quality. Tools with wiper flats should be replaced or reconditioned when they show signs of wear.

Q: Do wiper flats require different programming or toolpath adjustments?
A: Yes, because wiper flats allow for higher feed rates, you may want to adjust your toolpath settings to optimize speed without compromising quality. Proper feed and speed adjustments are key to getting the most out of wiper technology.

Indexable Tooling

Indexable Tooling Solutions

Machinists require reliable solutions to tackle intricate tasks efficiently. Indexable tooling provides exceptional flexibility, quality, durability, and delivers high-performance results. Customize your tooling for specific tasks by choosing the ideal combination of inserts and holders to optimize performance.

Solid Round Tools

Explore our SGS branded high-performance and versatile solid round tooling options. Our quality tooling not only ensures precision but also minimizes downtime, allowing for increased material removal per hour. Explore a range of options including end mills, drills, routers, countersinks, and more to find the perfect tools for your specific needs.

Share

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *